Comparison of Timurid vault and dome using computational methods of Al’Kashi models: the case of Goharshad Mosque, Mashhad

Document Type : Scientific Research

Authors

1 Ph.D. Student of Architecture, Architecture Department, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

2 Associate Professor, Department of Architecture, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran

3 Professor, Department of Architecture, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

4 Assistant Professor, Department of Architecture, Gilan University, Gilan, Iran

Abstract

Research Problem: The application of computational formulas has a major role in the geometry of Iranian architecture in the Timurid era.  What is interesting about the architecture of this period is the use of the ideas of Al’Kashi --a ninth century mathematician-- in measuring, calculating, and formulating the methods of constructing vaults and domes. One of the most important achievement of Ghiaseddin is related to triangulation. It was Mirza Abu Turab Natanzi, a mathematician of the Qajar era, who later dealt with this issue through a geometric method equivalent to Al’Kashi’s algebraic method.
Research Question: This research explores whether Al’Kashi has accurately considered computational operations in architecture or his thesis is just a practical and theoretical exercise. We also investigate whether Al’Kashi’s models are precise descriptions of existing vaults and whether the builder has carefully paid attention to Al’Kashi’s recommendations. To address these issues, we aim at discovering the relationships and explain the new computational rules proposed in Al’Kashi’s works.
Research Method: The research method is based on logical reasoning through precise mathematical propositions. The analytical tool includes Python programming language to be run in Rhino software, which could link computational rules and the Shape Grammars in Al’Kashi models.  The results of this evaluation are identified in the architectural elements of Goharshad Mosque, which corresponds to Al’Kashi 's presence in the region of Khorasan at the time the mosque was built. Computational exploration of architectural elements requires modeling and physical encoding. The predominant feature of Al’Kashi’s works is approaching architectural elements from a descriptive-analytical perspective. This method involves component-based classification, defining the parameters of the elements, and describing their resulting hierarchy. Therefore, our method is based on modeling in Rhino software. In addition, the Grasshopper extension and Python programming language were used to examine and determine computational relationships, the language of shapes between architectural elements (vault and dome), and Al’Kashi models based on the geometric system of Timurid architecture.  We first investigate how accurately Al’Kashi calculated the coefficients of the vaults; next, by referring to the dimensions and sizes of the vault and dome in the related building, we search for the roots of their geometric system in order to find the numerical correspondence of these ratios in Al’Kashi models.
The Most Important Results and Conclusion: The results suggested that Al’Kashi’s calculations and drawings are not merely a practical and theoretical exercise; rather, they have correctly used computational operations to develop architectural elements. Besides, there is a relationship between the computational rules of Al’Kashi models and the geometric system of the vault and dome of Goharshad Mosque. Indeed, Ghavam al-Din Shirazi, the architect of the Timurid court, has appropriately deployed the geometric system and computational rules of his time in the construction of this building. These findings reinforce the hypothesis that the ‘captains of industries’ used to obtain their mathematical and geometric knowledge through dialogue with contemporary intellectuals. Goharshad Mosque showcases the harmony and balance between the geometric and computational system of the Timurid era. 

Graphical Abstract

Comparison of Timurid vault and dome using computational methods of Al’Kashi models: the case of Goharshad Mosque, Mashhad

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Balachandran Pillai A. (2017). Software Architecture with Python: Design and architect highly scalable, robust, clean, and high performance applications in Python, 1th ed., Birmingham, Packt Publishing Ltd.
Bavandiyan, A. (2017). Value indexes of Gohrashad mosque in Mashhad from the perspective of intimacy wisdom, Razavi Culture. 5[17]: 209-230.
Connors D, Dunn K, Bueter, R. (2017).  PyCompArch: Python-Based Modules for Exploring Computer Architecture Concepts, Conference Paper, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304551365. Retrived: 01/2020.
Dold Samplonius Y. (2000). Kashani method for calculating arcs, tr. Ali Reza Ashrafi and Mohammad Reza Ahmadi. 2005. Mirror of Heritage (Ayene-ye Miras), 3: 61-77.
Doostgharin F. (2009). AbuTorab’s Treatise on Trisection of Angles, Journal for History of Science. 7[1]: 1-29.
Ekhlassi, A. Mofidi Shemirani, Majid and Anbari Ruzbahani, N. (2014). Algorithmic Design Approach (ADA) and Iranian Daylighting Techniques: How a Contemporary Transparent Façade Could Be Evolved From a Previous Solution. Armanshahr Architecture & Urban Development. 7[1]: 25-35.
Fallahi F, Mirriahi S, Soltanzadeh H, Raeis Samiei MM. (2020). The role of Trigonometric Rules in Iranian Architectural Elements from Al’Kashi’s Perspective, Philosophy of Science. 10[20]: 129-152.
Fallahnia m. Khosravi r, zareapour s. (2013). Algorithmic architecture is a tool for realizing new ideas International Conference on Civil Engineering Architecture & Urban Sustainable Development, Tabriz, Iran.
Ghazizadeh Rumi, M. (9th hegira century). Treatise on sine of one-degree extraction, version number 3180/11, Malek national library, Mashhad, Islamic Research Foundation.
Golabchi, M, Andaji Garmroodi A, Bastani H. (2012). Digital architecture and the application of CAD/CAM technologies in architecture, 2nd ed., Tehran, Tehran University.
Hillenbrand R. (2005). The Timurid Achievement, In: Architecture, A Survey of Persian Art FROM PREHISTORIC TIMES TO THE PRESENT: The Islamic Period, Vol. XVIII, Ed, Abbas Daneshvari, Costa Mesa: 83-126.
Hoseini M. (2014). Historical Mosques of Khorasan, 1th ed., Mashhad, Islamic Research Foundation.
Kashani GAJ. (9th hegira century). Treatise of ceiling and high-rise buildings, tr. Sayed Ali Reza Jazbi, 2014, 3rd ed., Tehran, Sorush.
Khayri A. (2010). The arch of Iranian-Islamic architecture in Jamshid Kashani’s Miftah Al-Hesab, the sciences and techniques book of month. 2[129]: 28-34.
Kostof S. (1977). The Architect in the middle Ages, East and West. In: Architect chapter in the history, ed., Kostof, Spiro, New York, Oxford University press: 59-95.
Mazaheri M. (1998). Architecture in the Timurid era, Glory of Art.; [8 & 9]: 46-51.
Masoumi Hamedani. H. (2006). Angle Trinity, Great Islamic Encyclopedia, Vol. 14, Tehran, Great Islamic Encyclopedia.
Memarian GH. (1987). Vaulted Structure in the Iranian Islamic
Architecture, Tehran, Jehad Daneshgahi, 1987.
Memarian Gh. H. Anwarul Islam M. Mousavian S. M. F. (2014). 15th century contribution to the study of vaulted structure in Iran based on Ghiayth-al Din Kashani’s studies. International Journal of Architectural Engineering & Urban Planning, Vol. 24, No. 1, 1-8.
Mostaghni AR, Alimoradi M. (2016). Analysis the application of the nature geometry and the fractal in parametric architecture: The Interior ornament of the dome of the Sheikh Lotfollah mosque, Architecture and Urban Planning. 8[16]: 103-122.
O’kane B. (2017). Architecture and Court Cultures of the Fourteenth Century, John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Ozdural A. (2000). Mathematics and Arts: Connections between Theory and Practice in the Medieval Islamic World, Historia Mathematica. 27[2]: 171-201.
Pope A. (1965). Persian Architecture, tr. Gholam Hosein Sadri Afshar, (2014). 10th ed., Tehran, Dat.
Rutten D. (2011). Python for Rhinoceros 5, Rhinocervs, Revision 3, http://designalyze.com/sites/default/files/tutorial_files/RhinoPythonPrimerRev3.pdf. Retrieved: 01/2020.
Sahragard M. (2012). Artistic Masterpieces in Astan Quds Razavi: Inscriptions of Goharshad Mosque, 1th ed., Mashhad, Artistic creations of Astan Quds Razavi.
Savadi F. (2008). A Persian Treatise on the Determination of the Sine of One Degree, Journal for History of Science. 6[1]: 69-104.
Shahabi R, Sadegh Foroughi M, Lashkari L, Kamelnia H. (2016). The place of parametric design in the formation of contemporary architecture of Islamic countries. International Congress on new Horizons in Architecture & planning, Tehran, Iran.
Shuriye AO. Daoud, Jamal I. (2011). Islamic Mathematical Sciences. Australian Journal of Basic and Applied Sciences. 5[3]: 51-59.  
Taheri J, Nourtagha’ei, A. (2011). The architectural mathematics’ knowledge in Kashani’s works, sciences and techniques book of the month. 2[52]: 121-130.
Tarzidis K. (2003). Form as the expresser of an approach to computer-based architecture, tr. Kaveh Bazrafkan, 2014, 1st ed., Mashhad, Kasra Bookstore.
Wilber D, Golombek L. (1988). The Timurid Architecture of Iran and Turan, tr. Keramatollah Afsar and Mohammad Yousof Kiani. 1995. 1th ed., Tehran, Country Cultural Heritage Organization.
Zemorshedi H. (2012). The unique Goharshad Mosque and the sacred arts of architecture, Iranian Islamic city studies. 2[6]: 17-32.
Journal of Architectural Thought
Volume 6, Issue 12 - Serial Number 12
September 2022
Pages 101-117

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics